Download Lluís Serra Majem - PAM

Document related concepts

Genómica nutricional wikipedia , lookup

Transcript
iDieta Mediterránea y Salud:
Estudios epidemiológicos de
observación y de intervención.
Lluís Serra Majem, MD, PhD.
Catedrático de Salud Pública de la
Universidad de Las Palmas de Gran Canaria
Presidente de la Fundación Dieta
Mediterranea
¿Dieta mediterránea?
¿Dietas mediterráneas?
1950s Ancel y Margaret Keys
Egipcios, griegos, romanos, fenicios,
árabes y cartagineses, ingerían
alimentos combinados y preparados
al estilo que hoy entendemos bajo la
noción de dietas mediterráneas.
Modelo alimentario prevalente en
algunas zonas europeas (Creta,…) a
mediados del siglo XX (OldwaysHarvard-OMS).
Origen de los principales alimentos
EUROPA
MEDITERRÁNEO
PRÓXIMO ORIENTE
INDIA Y ASIA
mediterráneos
DEL NORTE
Remolacha
Achicoria
Col
Colinabo
Espárragos
Mijo
Lentejas
Habas
Chufas
Centeno
Espelta
Escanda
Trigo blando
Cebada
Centeno
Mijo de India
Garbanzos
Sésamo
Pepino
Berenjena
Alcauciles
Rábanos
Nabos
Apios
Chirivías
Lechugas
Avena
Zanahorias
Cebollas
Ajos
Viñas
Alcachofa
Azafrán
Mostaza
Albahaca
Jengibre
Cardamomo
Canela
Cítricos
AMERICA
Maíz
Judías
Patatas
Pimientos
Calabacines
Calabazas
Tomate
Girasol
Cacao
Piña
Vainilla
Olivos
Alcachofas
Higueras
Almendros
Ciruelas
Melocotones
Melones
Cerezos
Albaricoques
Manzanos
Perales
Castaños
Nogales
Avellanos
Moras
Fuente: Adaptada de Igor de Garine “La dieta
mediterránea en el conjunto de los sistemas
alimentarios”Antropología de la alimentación: ensayos sobre
la dieta mediterránea. 1993
SURESTE ASIÁTICA/
OCEANÍA
Arroz
Caña de azúcar
Aves de corral
Romero
Pimienta
Nuez moscada
Clavo
Canela
AFRICA
Sandía
Palmeras
HISTORIA DE LA CERVEZA
Edad Media: ordenes monásticas
Cerevisia monacorum
Galos
Hispanos
Cervisia
Ceria
Romanos
Cerevisium
Fenicios
Griegos
Mesopotamia
Sumerios (4000 a.C.)
Sikaru
Egipcios
Zythum
Evolución
La confluencia geográfica,
histórica, antropológica y
cultural de tres
continentes: Europa, Asia
y África.
Un enclave de
comunicaciones e
influencias de tránsito
frecuente, con un hábitat
físico hospitalario y en un
entorno climatológico
templado.
Lograron configurarse un
patrón alimentario excelente
para la vida y la salud
Asimila algunas influencias y
alimentos foráneos alrededor
de sus productos básicos:
" el aceite de oliva, el trigo
y la vid (uva y vino)
" la carne de cerdo y
cordero y el pescado.
Características
ALTO CONSUMO
• Pan y derivados del trigo
• Verduras, frutas y hortalizas
MENOR
CONSUMO
• Legumbres, frutos secos
• Carne
• Aceite de oliva
• Leche de vaca y
mantequilla
• Ciertos derivados lácteos como
el queso y el yogur
• Pescado y vino
• Patatas
• Licores
Patrón histórico de la DM
Preferencia de una cierta variedad de alimentos
mínimamente procesados y, en la medida de lo
posible, frescos, de temporada y cultivados
localmente (lo que optimizaría el contenido y
propiedades saludables de micronutrientes y
antioxidantes en estos alimentos)
Població que considera molt saludables
els següents aliments. ENCAT 1992-93
Pastanaga
Enciam
Peix blanc
Mel
Pa integral
Arrós
Oli d’oliva
Carn vedella
Cigrons
Peix blau
Patates
Pasta
Pa
45
41
30
28
22
21
17
15
15
14
13
12
11
%
Població que considera molt saludables
els següents aliments. ENCAT 2002-03
Pastanaga
Enciam
Peix blanc
Mel
Pa integral
Arrós
Oli d’oliva
Carn vedella
Cigrons
Peix blau
Patates
Pasta
Pa
46
46
24
23
25
25
43
8
28
38
12
19
12
%
Aliments que considera imprescindibles o molt
importants en la definició de Dieta Mediterrània
Imprescindible Molt important
Llet
25
Brioxeria 1 7
Pasta
16
Cervessa 3 13
Vi
24
Llegums
33
Fruita seca
22
Marisc
15
Peix
Hort. i enciam
Fruita
Oli de girasol 3 15
Oli d'oliva
Iogurt
15
Formatge
14
Carn
12
Patates
15
Pa
20
0
10
56
53
42
54
53
44
33
43
37
41
62
57
65
51
20
30
33
54
56
53
40
51
50
60
70
80
90
100
Población española de 2 a 24 años con valores del Índice
Kidmed ≥ 8 por regiones geográficas.
Estudio enKid (1998-2000)
Norte 37,5%
Centro
45,7%
Noreste
52,1%
Levante 45,8%
Sur y Canarias
49,3%
Distribución de la población infantil y juvenil española
según nivel socioeconómico y valor del Test de Calidad
de la Dieta Mediterránea. (ENKID 1998-2000)
Nivel socioeconómico
Bajo Medio Alto
60
%
50
40
30
20
10
0
<=3
4-7
Índice KIDMED
>=8
1950
1. Estudis ecològics. Estudi dels Set Països
1970
2. Estudis clínic-epidemiològics sobre
aliments de la Dieta: nous, vi, fruites,
hortalisses, oli d’oliva, all, ceba, etc.
1980
3. Estudis clínic-epidemiològics sobre
nutrients/ingredients de la Dieta:
B-carotè, vitamina E, fibra, flavonoids, etc.
2000
4. Estudis epidemiològics sobre el conjunt
de la dieta. Utilització de index de dieta
saludable/mediterrània.
Epidemiological hierarchy in evidence based nutrition
Quality of the evidence
High
Low
Systematic
Systematic reviews
reviews
Meta
-analysis
Meta-analysis
Randomized
Randomized clinical
clinical trials
trials
Non
Non randomized
randomized clinical
clinical trials
trials
Cohort
Cohort studies
studies
Case
Case –– Control
Control studies
studies
Descriptive
Descriptive studies
studies
Evidence Based Nutrition and
Mediterranean Diet
Limitations to the application of evidence based
medicine to nutritional sciences:
• The modification of the diet needs collaboration
from the patient and environment
• Difficulty in analyzing dietary adherence
• Difficulty in developing double blind interventions
• Difficulty for making comparisons worldwide
Evidence Based Nutrition and
Mediterranean Diet
• High impact of Mediterranean diet on the public
(1,240,000 citations in Google®, 2006)
• Medium-low impact in Medline Current Sciences
(around 500 citations, 2005; around 725, 2007)
• Biased and personal reviews (more than 100) and few
systematic reviews.
• Scarce clinical trials. None on primary prevention.
• Most observational epidemiological studies (ecological,
case-control, cohorts).
• Relevant cohort studies in recent years and ongoing.
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet: Methods
Publications about Mediterranean diet since 1984
Search in MEDLINE for articles:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Mediterranean diet
Health
Cancer
Cardiovascular disease
Bone disease
Prevention
Mediterranean diet and health
Mediterranean diet and cancer prevention
Mediterranean diet and cardiovascular disease
Mediterranean diet and bone health,…
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet
• The term “Mediterranean diet” produced
416 studies in human subjects
• 128 of them were review articles
• 55 of them were clinical trials, 41 of them
randomized
• After excluding for language,
methodological constraints and studies
analyzing a unique Mediterranean food,
43 articles were selected
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet
Number and type of articles published
about the Mediterranean diet
90
80
Publications
Clinical trials
Reviews
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
19
84
19
85
19
86
19
87
19
88
19
89
19
90
19
91
19
92
19
93
19
94
19
95
19
96
19
97
19
98
19
99
20
00
20
01
20
02
20
03
20
04
Number of articles
100
Year of publication
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet
• The 43 clinical trials selected corresponded to
35 different studies
• Origin: Italy, Spain, France, Great Britain,
Chile, Sweden, Canada, Australia, USA,
Denmark, Finland, India
• Size ranged from 11 to 13,000 subjects
• From 28 days to 6,5 years of follow up
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet
Studies were classified into six groups:
ƒ Cardiovascular disease: 5 publications
ƒ Diabetes/lipoproteins/endothelial resistance: 30 pub.
ƒ Arthritis: 2 publications
ƒ Cancer: 1 publication
ƒ Body composition: 3 publications
ƒ Psychological function: 2 publications
Cardiovascular:
Author
/year pub.
Barzi F,
2003
Country
Type of study
Population
Methodology
Italy
Clinical Sec.
trial
Prev
N=11,323 M/W
surviving a MI
Subjects received advice to
increase consumption of fish,
fruit, raw and cooked vegetables
and olive oil
Singh,
2002
Moradabad RCT,
India
single
blind
499 individuals on a indo-MD
and 501 controls on a NCEP
diet for 2 years
2y
Sec.
Prev.
N=1000 subjects
with major risk
factors or
previous heart
attack
N=423 subjects
surviving a MI
Randomisation to a MD group
or control group
46 m
Sec.
Prev.
N= 605 subjects
surviving a MI
Randomisation to a MD group
or control group
27 m
Sec.
Prev.
N= 605 subjects
surviving a MI
Randomisation to a MD group
or control group
27 m
Lorgeril M, Lyon,
1999
France
Lorgeril M, Lyon,
1996
France
Lorgeril M, Lyon,
1994
France
RCT,
single
blind
RCT,
single
blind
RCT,
single
blind
Sec.
Prev.
Follow
up
6.5 y
Diabetes/lipoproteins/endothelial resistance:
Author
/year pub. Country
Type of study
Population
Vincent S, Marseille RCT
2004
France
Esposito K Naples,
RCT,
2004
Italy
singleblind
Ros E,
BCN,
R-cross2004
Spain
over-CT
Pri.
Prev.
Pri.
Prev.
Ambring
A, 2004
Goulet J,
2004
R-crossover-CT
Clinical
trial
Pri.
Prev.
Pri.
Prev.
Flynn G, Australia Clinical
2004
trial
Pri.
Prev.
Urquiaga Santiago
I, 2004
de Chile,
Chile
BravoCórdoba,
Herrera Spain
MD, 2004
Clinical
trial
Pri.
Prev.
N=21, M
R-crossover-CT
Pri.
Prev
N=41
Goteborg
Sweden
Quebec,
Canada
Pri.
Prev.
Methodology
Follow
up
N=212, M/W
>=1 CV RF
N=180, M/W
Metabolic
syndrome
N=21, M/W
hypercholesterolemic
MD or a traditional
3 m, still
low-fat/chol. diet
on going
Control group following a
24 m
prudent diet and interv. group
following a MD
4 w. chol. lowering MD /
4w
4 w. diet similar in E. and fat
content where walnuts replaced
∼ 32% E from MUFA
N=22, M/W
4 w. of a Swedish diet,
4w
healthy subj.
4 w. of a MD
N= 77, W
12 w. nutrition intervention
12 w
healthy
with 2 group sessions, 3 individual
sessions and 4 24-h recall
N=155, M/W
3 m. MD and control group
3m
non specific
3 m. MD or western diet.
The 2nd m. red wine was added to
both diets
3 dietary periods: SAT fat enriched
diet, low fat and high CHO diet,
MD
3m
3m
...
Diabetes/lipoproteins/endothelial resistance:
Author
Country
/year pub.
Toobert
Oregon,
DJ, 2003 USA
Type of study
Population
RCT
Sec.
Prev
N=279 W
postmenopausal DM2
R-crossover-CT
Clinical
trial
Sec.
Prev.
Pri.
Prev.
Rodríguez
V.C, 2003
Goulet J,
2003
Barcelona,
Spain
Quebec,
Canada
Sondergaard E,
2003
Svendborg, RCT
Denmark
Mezzano D Santiago
2003
de Chile,
Chile
Singh N, London,
2002
U.K.
Sec.
Prev.
Clinical
trial
Pri.
Prev.
RCT,
doubleblind
Perez
Cordoba, R-crossJimenez F, Spain
over-CT
2001
Mezzano D Santiago Clinical
2001
de Chile, trial
Chile
Pri.
Prev.
Pri.
Prev.
Pri.
Prev.
Methodology
Control: usual care. Interv.
group:3-d retreat and 6 m of
weekly meetings with diet, PA &
stress management modification
N=22 M/W
6 w. of a high CHO diet and 6 w.
with DM2
on a high MUFA diet or vice versa
N=77 W
12 w. nut. interv. with 2 group
sessions, 3 individual sessions and
4 24-h R
N=115 M/W 12 m. of statin treatment and MD
recent/remote
intervention group or control
MI or unstable
group
/stable Angor P.
N=42 healthy M 21 MD and 21 high-fat diet for 30
days, suppl. with red wine in both
groups from day 31 to 60
N=56 healthy
6 w. on a MD or vitamin C
M/W
supplements or placebo
N=59 young
M/W
28 days of a SFA enriched diet,
followed by 28 d. of a low fat, high
CHO diet or a MD and vice versa.
N=42 healthy M
21 subjects on a MD and 21
subjects on a high-fat diet for 30
days, suppl. with red wine in both
groups from day 31 to 60
Follow
up
6m
6w
12 w
12 m
3m
6w
28 d
3m
...
Diabetes/lipoproteins/endothelial resistance:
Author
Country Type of study
/year pub.
Fuentes F, Cordoba, R-cross- Pri.
2001
Spain
over-CT Prev.
Muñoz S, Barcelona, R-cross2001
Spain
over-CT
Zambon Barcelona, R-crossD, 2000 Spain
over-CT
Madigan Dublin,
C, 2000 Ireland
R-crossover-CT
Ryan M,
2000
Barbagallo CM,
1999
Leighton
F, 1999
Dublin,
Ireland
Palermo,
Italy
Clinical
trial
Clinical
trial
Chile
Cinical
trial
PérezJiménez
F, 1999
Córdoba, Clinical
Spain
trial
Population
N=22 M
hypercholesterolemic
Methodology
Follow
up
28 d
28 days of a SFA enriched diet,
followed by 28 days of a low fat,
high CHO diet (NCEP-1) or a MD
and vice versa.
Pri.
N=10 M
6 w. of a chol. lowering MD, 6 w.
6w
Prev.
hyperchoon a diet with walnut replacing
lesterolemic 35% E. from MUFA or vice versa
Pri.
N=49 M/W
6 w. of a chol. lowering MD, 6 w.
6w
Prev.
hypercholesof a diet with walnut replacing
terolemic
35% of the energy from MUFA
Sec.
N=11 M
2 w. MUFA rich diet (30ml olive
2w
Prev.
DM2
oil/day) and 2 w. PUFA rich diet
(30ml sunflower oil) & vice versa
Sec.
N= 11 M
2 m. on a PUFA rich diet and 2 m. 2 m
Prev.
DM2
on a MUFA rich diet (MD)
Sec. N=78 M/W renal
24 w. of usual diet and
10-12 w
Prev.
transplant
10-12 w. of MD
recipients
Pri.
N=21 M
3 m. on a MD or western diet. The 3 m
Prev.
2nd m. red wine was added to
both diets
Pri.
N= 25 M
28 days on a low fat NCEP-I-diet, 28 d
Prev.
or a MUFA-diet (MD) or a SFArich diet
...
Diabetes/lipoproteins/endothelial resistance:
Author
Country Type of study
/year pub.
Baroni SS, Italy
Clinical
Sec.
1999
trial
Prev.
Simoni G, Italy
1995
Clinical
trial
Salen,
1994
Clinical
trial
France
Methodology
Follow
up
Hypercholeste- MUFA enriched diet vs. a PUFA
rolemic patients
enriched diet
Clinical
trial
N=15 hypercho2 months on a Gemfibrozil
lesterolemic with (600mg) treatment combined
?Lp(a) patients
with MD
Sec.
N=41 M hyper18 months of MD
Prev. cholesterolemic
heart transplant
Pri.
N=90 pilots
a) Uncontrolled diet & exercise
Prev.
programme, b) MD & uncontrolled exercise, c) MD &
controlled exercise programme
Pri.
N=48 M/W
Shift from a MD to a MD high in
Prev.
saturated fats and cholesterol
Clinical
trial
Pri.
Prev.
Moreno Badajoz, Clinical
Vazquez Spain
trial
JM, 1994
FerroItaly
,
Luzzi
1984
Ehnholm North
C, 1982
Karelia,
Finland
Population
Sec.
Prev.
N=54
MD
2m
18 m
42 d
6w
Arthritis:
Author
Country Type of study
/year pub.
Sköldstam L, Sweden clinical Sec.
2003
trial
Prev.
Hagfors L,
2003
Sweden RCT
Sec.
Prev.
Population
Methodology
Follow
up
12 w
N= 51 M/W
rheumatoid
arthritis patients
N=51 M/W
rheumatoid
arthritis patients
12 w. on either MD
or control diet
3 m on either MD
or control diet
3m
Population
Methodology
N=605 subjects
surviving a MI
MD group or
control group.
Follow
up
4y
Cancer:
Author
Country Type of study
/year pub.
Lorgeril M, Lyon,
RCT
Sec.
1998
France
Prev.
Body composition:
Author
/year pub.
Flynn G,
2004
Country Type of study
Population
Methodology
Australia clinical Prim.
trial
Prev.
N= 41
individuals
41 individuals followed for 15 m
after completing a 3 m MD
N=34 M
hypercholesterolemics who
consumed a diet
rich in SAT fat
N=101 M/W
overweight
Each of 17 subjects underwent
two dietary periods of 28 days:
MD/carbohydrate rich diet
28 d
MD versus low fat diet
18 m
Population
Methodology
N=120 M
untreated
hypercholesterolemic
N=176
hypercholesterolemic subjects
MD versus simvastatin
treatment
Follow
up
12 w
Fernandez Córdoba, clinical Sec.
de la Puebla Spain
trial
Prev.
RA, 2003
McManus K, Boston,
2001
USA
RCT
Prim.
Prev.
Follow
up
3m
Psychological function:
Author
Country Type of study
/year pub.
Hyyppä MT, Turku, R-cross- Sec.
2003
Finland over-CT Prev.
Wardle J,
2000.
London, RCT
United
Kingdom
Sec.
Prev.
12 w of a low fat diet,
or MD or control group
12 w
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet. Results
The Mediterranean diet produced:
¾ An improvement in lipoprotein levels (especially total
cholesterol and LDL-cholesterol) (HIGH)
¾ Favorable effects on endothelial function (HIGH)
¾ An improvement in glycemic control, via plasma glucose,
insulin and HbA1 levels and insulin resistance (HIGH)
¾ An improvement in antioxidant capacity (MEDIUM)
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet. Results
The Mediterranean diet produced (cont.):
¾ Favorable effects on myocardial and cardiovascular
mortality in cardiac patients (HIGH)
¾ An improvement in some functional tests for arthritis
(LOW)
¾ A lower risk of incidence for some kinds of malignant
and nonmalignant tumors (LOW)
¾ An improvement in BMI, % body fat and other
anthropometric measures (MEDIUM)
¾ No evidence of mood changes
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet
Discussion
• Scientific evidence for Mediterranean diet
is based on observational studies or
personal reviews
• Most of the trials used a sample of less
than 60 subjects
• Major differences exist in the methodology
used to analyze the intervention (MD)
La Jerarquía de la Evidencia Científica
para la epidemiología nutricional
Calidad de la evidencia
Alta
Baja
Revisiones
áticas
Revisiones sistem
sistemáticas
Meta
-análisis
Meta-análisis
Ensayos
ínicos aleatorizados
Ensayos cl
clínicos
aleatorizados
Estudios
Estudios controlados
controlados no
no aleatorizados
aleatorizados
Estudios
Estudios de
de cohorte
cohorte
Casos
Casos -- Controles
Controles
Serie
Serie de
de casos
casos
1950
1. Estudis ecològics. Estudi dels Set Països
1970
2. Estudis clínic-epidemiològics sobre
aliments de la Dieta: nous, vi, fruites,
hortalisses, oli d’oliva, all, ceba, etc.
1980
3. Estudis clínic-epidemiològics sobre
nutrients/ingredients de la Dieta:
B-carotè, vitamina E, fibra, flavonoids, etc.
2000
4. Estudis epidemiològics sobre el conjunt
de la dieta. Utilització de index de dieta
saludable/mediterrània.
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet.
Discussion
Observational studies:
¾ SUN Cohort Study (Navarra, España): Med diet
and different end points (mortality, HTA, obesity,..)
(19.000 men and women)
¾ EPIC Study (Several european countries): Med diet,
cancer and cardiovascular diseases (650.000 males
and females)
¾ HALE study (Several european countries): Med diet
and longevity (3.000 elderly males and females).
¾ NURSES study (USA): Med diet and diabetes,…
(65.000 women).
• Los ancianos en el quintil superior de consumo
de cereales tienen más de un 20% de descenso
de riesgo cardiovascular (JAMA, 2003)
• La ingesta de cereales integrales (2 rebanadas
de pan integral por día) supone un riesgo menor
de infarto de miocardio o embolia (Am J Geriatr
Cardiol, 2004)
• Un patrón de ingesta con un elevado consumo
de derivados lácteos bajos en grasas, y
alimentos ricos en fibra se asocia con un menor
IMC en mujeres (Am J Clin Nutr, 2004)
• Un aumento en la ingesta total de fibra (12g) se
asocia con una disminución en la circunferencia
de cintura después de 9 años de seguimiento en
hombres (Am J Clin Nutr, 2003)
• En la mujeres del estudio EPIC, el consumo de
cereales predecía una disminución del peso tras
dos años de seguimiento (OR = 1.43; 95% CI,
1.09-1.88), (J Nutr, 2002)
• Una dieta rica en fruta, verdura, productos
integrales y productos lácteos bajos en grasas y
baja en carne roja, comidas preparadas, fast food
y soda se asocia con una menor ganancia en el
IMC y la circunferencia de cintura (Am J Clin Nutr,
2003)
40
Patrón histórico de la DM:
Condimentos
Utilización de ajo,
cebolla, hierbas y
especias
• Sabor, higiene y conservación
• El perejil, la menta, la
albahaca y el cilantro
contienen cantidades no
despreciables de calcio, hierro
y vitaminas A y C
• Alto contenido en flavonoides
(hinojo, cebollina, etc)
• Compuestos aliáceos (ajo,
cebolla) – posible efecto
cardiosaludable y mejora en
funciones cognitivas
Disponibilidad de frutos secos (kg/per cápita/año) en
distintos países según las hojas de Balance alimentario de
la FAO. Año 1990.
Venezuela
Tailandia
Uruguay
Japón
Reino Unido
Marruecos
EE.UU.
Suecia
Dinamarca
Portugal
Israel
Bolivia
Italia
Túnez
Turquía
España
Suiza
Grecia
0
2
4
6
Kg/per cápita/año
8
10
Disponibilidad de frutos secos (kg/per cápita/año) en
distintos países según las hojas de Balance alimentario de
la FAO. Año 2000.
Venezuela
Uruguay
Tailandia
Japón
Reino Unido
Suecia
EE.UU.
Marruecos
Dinamarca
Portugal
Turquía
Israel
Bolivia
Italia
Túnez
España
Suiza
Grecia
0
2
4
6
Kg/per cápita/año
8
10
Traditional Mediterranean Diet:
Fish
Weekly intakes in low to
moderate amounts of fish,
shellfish, poultry and including
some eggs per week.
• PUFA found in fish oils
(eicosapentainoic acid –EPA;
docosahexaenoic acid- DHA)
• Efficacy regulating haemostatic factors
• Protective effect seen for cardiac
arrhythmia, and for cancer in animals
• Role in maintenance of neuronal function
and affects certain psychiatric disorders
• 18:3/18:2 Ratio around 1:4
DIETA MEDITERRÁNEA
• 90 PACIENTES CON SM SIGUEN DIETA
MEDITERRÁNEA, 90 SIGUEN DIETA
NORMAL
• CON DIETA MEDITERRÁNEA:
– 4 KG PÉRDIDA DE PESO (FRENTE 1 KG
GRUPO CONTROL)
– MENOR RESISTENCIA A INSULINA
– 67% DEJAN DE TENER SM (FRENTE
19% GRUPO CONTROL)
Esposito K, Marfella R, Ciotola M, Di Palo C, Giugliano F, Giugliano G, D'Armiento M, D'Andrea F, Giugliano
D.Effect of a mediterranean-style diet on endothelial dysfunction and markers of vascular inflammation in the
metabolic syndrome: a randomized trial. JAMA 2004;292(12):1440-6.
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet.
Discussion
Ongoing randomised clinical trials:
¾Mediet Project (Italy): Med diet and cancer
(115 women)
¾Medi RIVAGE study (France): Med diet,
cardiovascular risk and gene polymorphism
(212 males and females)
¾PREDIMED study (Spain)
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet:
PREDIMED study
Coordinator: R. Estruch, MD (H. Clìnic, Barcelona)
• Parallel group, multi-center, randomized study
• N=9000 high risk individuals (55 to 80 years for males and
60 to 80 years for females)
• 3 groups: low fat diet (AHA), Mediterranean diet (olive
oil), Mediterranean diet (walnuts, hazelnuts, almonds)
• Primary outcome: cardiovascular death, non-fatal
myocardial infarction, non-fatal stroke/Secondary
outcome: death by any cause, incidence of angina leading
to revascularization procedure, heart failure, diabetes
mellitus, dementia and cancer/Other outcomes: changes in
blood pressure, body weight, adiposity measures, blood
sugar, lipid profile, markers of inflammation, other
intermediate markers of cardiovascular risk
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet
• Mediterranean diet recommendations need to be
evidence based, which implies the development
of clinical and observational epidemiology in
Mediterranean countries
• Objective systematic reviews need to address
different areas of associations with health and
personal reviews should not be accepted.
• Otherwise the promotion of the Mediterranean
diet will always have certain shortcomings
Scientific Evidence of interventions
on the Mediterranean Diet
Scientific evidence of interventions on the
Mediterranean Diet: A systematic review
Serra-Majem L, Roman B, Estruch R
Nutrition Reviews, 2005.
Evolución social del entorno alimentario mediterráneo
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Reducción y modificación de la família
Incorporación de la mujer al trabajo
Mayor estrés y menor actividad física
Incremento comidas fuera de casa y platos
precocinados
Menos dedicación a la cocina, falta de aprendizaje
Cambioss en los patrones de compra y provisión
Incorporació de alimentos-costumbres importados
Retroceso de las costumbres tradicionales
Mediterráneas y Globalización.
Pirámides de la alimentación actual
PDM
Monthly
Weekly
Optimum MD:
Around 1960
Daily
- Quantities?
- Varieties?
- Dairy?
- Refined Cereals?
- OH in moderation?
Wine moderation
62
Muchas gracias por su
atención.
Lluís Serra Majem, Fundación Dieta Mediterránea